All Posts By

Mapping Media Freedom

Europe’s journalists face growing climate of fear

By | Mapping Media Freedom, Quarterly reports
May 2015

Journalists and media workers continue to confront relentless pressure as they do their jobs, according to a survey of the verified incidents reported to Index on Censorship’s Mapping Media Freedom project.

For the past year, Index on Censorship has been recording threats to media freedom in the European Union and candidate countries via its Mapping Media Freedom project. Since the mapping project was launched, over 760 reports — including 89 physical attacks on journalists — from across Europe have been verified and published.

Thirteen media workers have been killed in connection with their jobs. Journalists have been assaulted. Media workers have been threatened with death or bodily harm. Police and government officials have detained and interrogated reporters. Journalists have been burned in effigy, depicted as animals on billboards and subjected to online trolling. Newspaper articles have been spiked in opaque circumstances. Television programmes have been cancelled amid accusations of censorship. Extremist groups have attacked media offices while hackers have knocked news sites off the web.

This is the Europe chronicled by the reports published to Mapping Media Freedom — covering European Union member states and candidates for entry — between May 2014 and April 2015. Taken together, these reports show that far from being an isolated problem, press freedom and media professionals face mounting pressure across the continent.

While no country is immune from pressures on media professionals, the five countries with the most reports were EU candidate country Turkey (114), member state Hungary (93), candidate country Serbia (74), founding member state Italy (71) and founding member state Germany (48). The successor nations to the former Yugoslavia had a combined total of 174 incidents that were verified by correspondents attached to the project.

The map, which was co-funded by the European Commission, launched publicly on 24 May 2014 in cooperaton with Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso and allows anyone — from members of the public to journalist unions — to submit reports for verification by Index’s eight part-time European Union correspondents.

“The truly frightening thing is that the current 762 reports represent ‘just the tip of the iceberg’, as one of our correspondents put it. More awareness among journalists about media violations is needed, but the reports point to the scale of the problem”, Index Senior Advocacy Officer Melody Patry said.

Mediafreedom-042815

Countries with the most reports in 2014-2015

The 10 countries with the most incidents reported to mappingmediafreedom.org as of April 21 2015. The project includes all European Union member states and potential candidates for entry. Cases cited are the most recent verified report for that country.

Turkey Turkey 114 reports
Journalist and academic Osman Özsoy said on his Twitter account that he had been detained by counterterrorism police
Hungary Hungary 93 reports
Miklós Borsa, a news anchor for Hungarian public television, was assaulted in the township of Balatonfüred

Serbia Serbia 74 reports
Photographer Senad Zupljanin was physically assaulted by a member of the Novi Pazar city council’s security detail
Italy Italy 71 reports
Sports journalist Matteo Spini was targeted with a banner, chants and threats in private messages and comments on social media

Germany Germany 48 reports
The office building of the newspaper Die Leipziger Volkszeitung‘s (LVZ) regional bureau in Eilenburg, a small city near Leipzig, was vandalised
France France 41 reports
Journalist Simon Michel was attacked in Arles by bullfighting professionals while he was covering an anti-bullfighting protest

Romania Romania 39 reports
Stelian Tanase, director of Romanian Public Television, wrote to the Romanian Intelligence Service requesting removal of undercover agents from his staff
Bosnia Bosnia 30 reports
News agency Patria was inaccessible for around 12 hours as a consequence of a hacker attack

United Kingdom United Kingdom 29 reports
More than 30 jobs have been made redundant or put at risk of redundancy by Newsquest
fist web size North Macedonia 25 reports
Reporter and editor Borjan Jovanovski was sent a funeral wreath with “Final Greetings” written on it

 

Case Studies

Across Europe, censorship and media violations take different forms depending on the country. These four reports are expanded from incidents that were logged to the map. Read more in-depth reporting.

Germany

Vandals lash out against local newspaper for reporting on right-wing extremists



“People like to make journalists their victims and to take revenge out on them. Usually, somebody does something bad and the journalist who uncovers that becomes the face of the issue.”

Lithuania

Russian language television network banned for “inciting discord”



“It is the first time in the history of the European Union that a regulatory body has taken the decision to take the whole channel completely off air.”


Montenegro

Journalist groups call impunity the biggest threat to media freedom



“Such an atmosphere of impunity threatens journalists in particular. If the state treats these attacks passively, it becomes responsible for the suppression of freedom of speech, the rule of law and democracy.”

Serbia

For Juzne Vesti editor, deteriorating media freedom comes as no surprise



“The language from the 90s is back in Serbia. Again, journalists that criticise the work of the government or are reporting on corruption are labelled as foreign mercenaries.”


 

Categorisation of violations

Reports can be filtered by the 51 different labels used to organise the incidents reported to mediafreedom.ushahidi.com

Legal measures

legal-measures
Incidents that involved the threat of or filing of legal actions

Censorship

Cases involving censorship
Incidents that included partial or complete censorship

Government threat

Cases involving government
Incidents that originated from a government representative or agency

 

Co-Funded by
logo_EC

This information is also available in a PDF format.

Lithuania bans Russian language channel for “inciting discord”

By | Features, Mapping Media Freedom

map-040915

Lithuania has banned a Russian TV channel for “inciting discord, warmongering [and] spreading disinformation” according to the country’s media regulator.

RTR Planeta, the international broadcasting service for the All-Russia State Television and Radio Broadcasting Company (VGTRK), a powerful state run media empire that operates more than a dozen TV channels and radio stations, will be taken off the air after alleged “incitements to hatred” during the Sunday Evening With Vladimir Solovjev program. Read More

For Juzne Vesti editor, Serbia’s deteriorating media freedom comes as no surprise

By | Features, Mapping Media Freedom

Working as a professional journalist in Serbia is hard. Being one in the country’s inland is even harder. Out of the 58 verified incidents involving Serbian media outlets and professionals reported to Index on Censorship’s European Union-funded Mapping Media Freedom, 30 have occurred outside Belgrade; the country’s political, economic and media capital. Four of these incidents have been directed at Juzne Vesti staff.

Launched in 2010 by journalist Predrag Blagojevic, Juzne Vesti is an independent news site based in Nis, a town of 257.000 in southern Serbia. In just over five years, its journalists have been subjected to verbal harassment or death threats 15 times. Though they have reported the incidents to local authorities, it has not resulted in convictions. Read More

Lithuania: Press freedom groups decry proposed bans on Russian TV channels

By | Features, Mapping Media Freedom

A coalition of international press freedom organisations has hit out at a move to force some Russian “government-controlled” TV stations off Lithuanian airwaves.

Lithuania’s Committee on Radio and Television is reportedly considering, at the request of the government, to ban two Russian television channels from broadcasting to the Baltic country.

The channels in question — RTR Planeta and NTV Mir Lithuania — have in the past been handed down temporary suspensions of specific programs, according to the commission head Edmundas Vaitiekunas.

“If a ban is imposed on the whole channel due to repeated violations, I believe it should be longer … I believe it should be up to one year,” Vaitiekunas added in comments to the Baltic News Service earlier this year. Read More

Long line of unresolved attacks scars Serbian journalism

By | Features, Mapping Media Freedom, Serbia

Around 1 am on Thursday 3 July 2014, Davor Pasalic, editor of Serbian news agency FoNet, was brutally assaulted as he made his way home from the office. Pasalic, who had stopped for pizza, was accosted by three young men who demanded money and told him they had a gun. Pasalic refused and the men began beating him while shouting nationality-based slurs. Pasalic estimates that they struck him about 30 times before leaving him alone. The injured man then crossed a bridge leading to his apartment and was again attacked by the three men. The two attacks left him with cuts and bruises to his head and body. Four of his teeth were broken or knocked out.

“I have no clue why those three guys attacked me,” Pasalic told Index on Censorship. “One of the guys asked me: Are you a Croat?  I was born in Belgrade. I have no accent. I look like every other citizen of Belgrade. Nobody has ever asked me that question before. How did he figure out that I am ethnic Croat?” Read More